Skip to content

10 mistakes to avoid with pre-screening tests

mistakes should you avoid with pre-screening tests

What are pre-screening tests?

Pre-screening tests are short assessments taken after the CV sift and before interview. They give you consistent evidence about each applicant, so you can reduce a large pool to a shortlist worth interviewing. Used well they save time for you and for candidates; used badly they screen out good people on something the job never needed. Here are the ten mistakes we see most, and what to do instead.

Common mistakes with pre-screening tests

1. Removing human judgement

Automating the first stage is sensible; automating the decision is not. A test tells you who to look at more closely. The decision still needs a person who has read the whole picture.

2. Using the score as the only data

A test result is one input. Read it alongside experience, the interview and a work sample. A candidate with a middling score and a strong work sample is a different proposition from one with a middling score and nothing else.

3. Ignoring reasonable adjustments

Timed tests can disadvantage candidates with dyslexia, ADHD or other conditions. Tell candidates up front that adjustments are available, such as extra time, and apply them when asked. A process that cannot accommodate neurodiverse candidates is both unfair and a smaller talent pool.

4. Choosing the wrong tests

The most common mistake. A logical reasoning test for a receptionist, or a personality quiz for a developer, measures something the job does not need. Start from the two or three things the person must do and pick tests that match: a software test for a role that lives in software, a situational judgement test for one built on everyday decisions, numerical reasoning for one that interprets figures.

5. Creating an impersonal experience

An unexplained test link from a no-reply address tells candidates they are a number. Explain what the test is, why you use it and what happens next, and sign the invitation.

6. Using only one test

One short test is a noisy measure. Two to four tests that cover different aspects of the job give a far better picture, and protect a good candidate from one bad ten minutes.

7. Over-automating

Automatic rejection below a cut-off, without a human glance, loses candidates who were a point short on one measure and strong on everything else. Use thresholds to order the pile, not to empty it.

8. Ignoring the candidate experience

Long assessments, repeated logins and no feedback drive away the strongest applicants, who have other offers. Keep the total under about forty minutes, make it work on a phone and tell everyone the outcome.

9. Ignoring the integrity of the result

Online tests can be taken with help. Use a platform that records how the test was sat, mix knowledge tests with timed reasoning tests, and ask a related question at interview. Our guide on whether candidates can cheat covers this in detail.

10. Ghosting applicants

Every candidate who completed your test gave you twenty minutes of their time. A short message with the outcome costs nothing and protects your reputation with the people who may apply next year.

Plan for success

Define the role's essential skills, choose tests that measure them, keep the assessment short, explain it to candidates, treat the score as evidence rather than a verdict, and review after a few hires whether the tests predicted who did well. Test Candidates gives you a full library of ability, skills and personality tests, integrity checks on every report and your first candidate results free, so you can set the process up properly before you pay for anything.

Send your first assessment today

5 free candidate results · No credit card required